Corruption In Mexico: U.S. Can’t Fund Mexican Army Units Because Of Human Rights Violations

RTR35EMF
Mauricio Guizar (C), also known as "El Amarillo", stands between two members of Mexico's navy (SEMAR) in an undisclosed location in this July 26, 2012 photograph released to Reuters on July 27. Mexico arrested one of the top traffickers for the Zetas drug cartel who is accused of overseeing the feared gangs' operations across the south of the country, the navy said on Friday. Naval forces captured Guizar on Thursday in a hotel in a small town in the central state of Puebla, where he was holed up with 20 grenades, an anti-tank bazooka and a submachine gun, the navy said in a statement. Picture taken July 26, 2012. REUTERS/Semar/Handout

Human rights violations, corruption, and collaboration with cartels is so common among some sections of the Mexican military that multiple U.S. agencies have stopped funding them. The U.S. Army recently declared an entire battalion of Mexican Army troops ineligible for American assistance, according to documents obtained by the National Security Archive, and a Latin Times source confirms that the DEA has been avoiding sections of Mexican military for years because of their reputation for misconduct. At the heart of the most recent allegations are troops from the Mexican Secretary of National Defense, known as SEDENA, have been blacklisted following allegations of massacring 22 people last June. An executive U.S. military summary known as a Bottom Line Up Front (BLUF) stated the following:

“The Government of Mexico has detained and charged seven SEDENA personnel in conjunction with the killing of twenty-two individuals on 30 June 2014 in San Pedro Limon, Tlatlaya, Mexico State. The unit implicated is not ineligible to receive U.S. assistance, and none of the alleged perpetrators previously received U.S. assistance.”

SEDENA initially denied the massacre saying that the 22 men, suspected members of the La Familia Michoacana cartel were killed in a firefight. However, forensic evidence and witness testimony suggested that they men had surrendered, and were executed extrajudicially, one by one. Mexico’s human rights commission now confirms that the SEDENA soldiers altered the crime scene. In addition to the 7 soldiers charged with murder, 28 officials are being investigated for the coverup which allegedly included the torture of detained witnesses.   

RTR35EMF Mauricio Guizar (C), also known as "El Amarillo", stands between two members of Mexico's navy (SEMAR) in an undisclosed location in this July 26, 2012 photograph released to Reuters on July 27. Mexico arrested one of the top traffickers for the Zetas drug cartel who is accused of overseeing the feared gangs' operations across the south of the country, the navy said on Friday. Naval forces captured Guizar on Thursday in a hotel in a small town in the central state of Puebla, where he was holed up with 20 grenades, an anti-tank bazooka and a submachine gun, the navy said in a statement. Picture taken July 26, 2012. REUTERS/Semar/Handout

The U.S report, authored by a human rights working group under the Northern Command acknowledged that the case raised “alarming questions about the widespread nature of cartel violence in the region and the level of government complicity.” Yet Tlatlaya isn’t the only place where SEDENA troops aren’t trusted, and the Army isn’t the only U.S. institution who’s unwilling to fund them. The DEA has slowly shifted funding away from SEDENA after it earned a reputation among law enforcement officials for corruption and brutality, according to a source familiar with DEA operations in Mexico. Instead, the agency has fed more work to SEMAR, the Mexican equivalent of the Navy and Marines.

The DEA did not immediately respond to a request for details on its partnerships with SEDENA and SEMAR.

In the wake of the murder of the 43 Ayotzinapa students in Guerrero last fall, questions continue to be not just about corruption, but active participation in cartel operations and SEDENA misdeeds. The federal government denies any involvement in the disappearance of the students, putting the blame squarely on local officials. In the Ayotzinapa case, it’s clear that the local mayor and some local police officers were involved in the disappearances. However, early confessions by local officials may have to poisoned by coercion. Like officials who tortured witnesses in the SEDENA cover-up, federal interrogators in the Ayotzinapa case raised more questions about the government than answers.

According to Michael Evans of the National Security Archive (which revealed the Bottom Line Up Front document), the U.S. and Mexico have stronger security ties than ever before.

“The U.S. has provided some $3 billion in security assistance to Mexican forces since 2008, in addition to billions more in direct military sales and other aid. Franzblau and Currier cite a diplomatic cable published by Wikileaks to ‘show how U.S.-Mexico security and intelligence relations have reached unparalleled levels of intimacy’ in recent years. The 2010 cable from the U.S. Embassy in Mexico City stresses that U.S. ‘ties with the Military’ at that time had ‘never been closer in terms of not only equipment transfers and training’ but also ‘intelligence exchanges.’”

Those intelligence exchanged have yielded many victories for the DEA and others, including the recent capture of top cartel leaders. However, Mexican military embarrassments are flying in the face of ongoing security initiatives that form the cornerstone of America's War on Drugs. Unless SEDENA can correct its apparently system problems, U.S. agencies will continue to move to other agencies. What’s to say that SEMAR, the Mexican Marines, won’t absorb corrupt practices as their role in counter-narcotics is elevated? Given the string of misdeeds committed by so many of Mexico’s law enforcement agencies, American taxpayers funding the fight may have some questions of their own.

What do you think?