In a dramatic turn in one of America's most infamous criminal cases, a California judge has resentenced Lyle and Erik Menendez—convicted of killing their parents in 1989—reducing their punishment from life without parole to 50 years to life.
The ruling makes the Menéndez brothers immediately eligible to apply for parole after serving more than 35 years behind bars.
Historic decision in Los Angeles
Los Angeles County Superior Court Judge Michael Jesic handed down the decision Tuesday, clarifying that although it's not his role to determine whether the brothers should be released, he believes they've earned the right to be considered by a parole board.
"I'm not saying they should be released," Jesic said, "but I think they've done quite a bit over the past 35 years and should have that opportunity."
The resentencing was granted under California's youthful offender law, which allows for the review of sentences handed down to individuals who committed serious crimes before turning 26. Lyle was 21 and Erik was 18 when they fatally shot their parents, José and Kitty Menéndez, inside their Beverly Hills mansion.
A defense based on abuse and rehabilitation
During the resentencing hearings, the defense presented testimony supporting the brothers' rehabilitation. Both earned college degrees while in prison and have actively participated in mediation and leadership programs. Additionally, family members, including their cousin Anamaría Baralt, testified on their behalf, stating that their family has forgiven them and that they deserve a second chance.
The defense has also argued that the brothers acted in self-defense after years of sexual and psychological abuse by their father, a claim that has gained renewed attention following the emergence of new evidence and testimony.
Opposition from the Prosecutor's Office and next steps
Despite the judge's decision, the prosecution, led by Nathan Hochman , strongly opposes the brothers' release. Hochman argues that the Menendez brothers have not fully taken responsibility for their actions and have maintained a narrative of lies about the events.
The state parole board will be in charge of deciding whether the brothers can be released. Additionally, California Governor Gavin Newsom has the authority to grant them clemency. Clemency hearings have been scheduled for June 13, one for each brother.
A case that continues to capture public attention
The Menendez brothers' case has once again captured public attention thanks to documentaries and television series exploring their story. The recent Netflix series, "Monsters: The Story of Lyle and Erik Menendez," has generated renewed interest and debate about justice and domestic abuse.
With the possibility of parole on the horizon, the Menendez brothers' case continues to be a topic of national discussion, raising questions about rehabilitation, justice, and the impact of abuse on criminal behavior.
