The ladies of Fifth Harmony had a super exciting night at the Billboard Music Awards 2016. Not only did they perform at the BBMAs for the first time ever, but they got to sing their latest single “Work from Home” which earned the group their first top 10 hit on the Billboard Hot 100 and is the first song to reach the top 10 from a girl group since 2008.

Before Ally Brooke, Normani Kordei, Dinah Jane, Camila Cabello and Lauren Jauregui headed inside to the show, the five beauties walked the pink carpet and talked to Billboard where they had to pick which Spice Girl they would have been. “One of pop culture's burning questions revealed! Which ‪#SpiceGirl would ‪@FifthHarmony be?,” Billboard tweeted along with a video.

Check out whom the ladies picked and see if you could have guessed their answers.

Fifth Harmony’s record-breaking success on the charts adds to an already award-winning 2016, with the group’s first-time wins at the iHeartRadio Music Awards and People’s Choice Awards, their second win at this year’s Kids Choice Awards and two wins at the Radio Disney Music Awards. 

In 2015, Fifth Harmony released their debut album, Reflection, which debuted at No. 5 on the Billboard 200 and has since been certified Gold. Reflection includes two platinum records, “BO$$” and “Sledgehammer” in addition to the quadruple-platinum success of the single, “Worth It.”

The latter track, which features Kid Ink, soared up the Billboard Hot 100 chart, catapulted to No. 4 on the Pop Songs airplay chart and was certified 3 times platinum, making it the group’s highest-certified single to date.

Named Group of the Year at the 2015 Billboard Women in Music event, Fifth Harmony closed out the year with honors at the MTV VMAs, MTV EMAs, MTV Fandom Awards, Teen Choice Awards, Kids’ Choice Awards, YouTube Music Awards and Radio Disney Music Awards.